| YEAR | RESULT | HALE SCORERS | CONQUERING HALE | BALL WINNER |
| 1856 | | Married v Unmarried Men | H Hutchinson | Wm Scott |
| 1857 | 2-1 SM | T Rogers 2 (M) | T Rogers (M) | A Maule |
| 1858 | 2-1 St M | Reay (M), Goodfellow (P), Simm (M) | Simm (M) | L Curran |
| 1859 | 1-0 St M | M | (M) | A Maule |
| 1860 | 2-1 St M | (M), (P), (M) | (M) | J Schofield |
| 1861 | 2-0 St M | Wm Smart (M), R Forster (M), 2 games 2nd unofficial | R Forster (M) | (Telfer DQ) G Alderson |
| 1862 | 2-1 St P | J Orange (M), J Brewis (P), J Goodfellow (P) | J Goodfellow (P) | G Alderson |
| 1863 | 1-0 St M | J Anderson (M) | J Anderson (M) | J Allen |
| 1864 | 2-1 St M | W Dunlop (M), M Oliver (P), J Young (M) | J Young (M) | W Renwick/ H Schofield |
| 1865 | Cancelled | Death of the 5th Duke of Northumberland | | |
| 1866 | 2-1 St M | M Patterson (P), H Morrison (M), J Garderner (M) | J Garderner (M) | W Dunlop, J Knox |
| 1867 | 2-0 St P | (P), J Matthews (P) | J Matthews (P) | G Egdell |
| 1868 | Cancelled | The late 5th Duke`s Escutcheon still on display (d1867) | | |
| 1869 | 2-0 St P | (P), Wm Robinson | Wm. Robinson (P) | Wm. White, G Balmbro |
| 1870 | 2-0 St M | J Curran or J Davis (M), W Rogerson (M) | W Rogerson (M) | A Maule |
| 1871 | 2-1 St P | T Dunn (M), A White (P), J Elliot (P) | J Elliot (P) | A Goodfellow |
| 1872 | 2-1 St P | J Black (M), (P) No record | No record(P) | R Dickson/R Dunlop |
| 1873 | Cancelled | Adverse weather | | |
| 1874 | 2-1 St M | J Moor (M), (P), T Douglas (M) | T Douglas (M) | J Lundy |
| 1875 | 2-1 St M | G Egdell (P), (M), J Percy (M) | J Percy (M) | G Egdell |
| 1876 | 2-1 St M | Undecided, J Allen (M) | J Allen (M) | W White |
| 1877 | 2-1 St M | G Egdell (P), (M), J Percy (M) | J Percy (M) | G Egdell |
| 1878 | 1-0 St M | (M) | Undecided (M) | W White |
| 1879 | 2-1 St M | W Duns (M), (P), J Moor (M) | J Moor (M) | W White |
| 1880 | 2-1 St P | W Hind (M), G Balmbra (P), G Balmbra (P) | G Balmbra(P) | No record |
| 1881 | 2-1 St M | W Hind(M), T Bell (P), W Wakenshaw/R Moore (M) | W Wakenshaw/R Moore (M) | G Egdell |
| 1882 | 2-1 St P | P Falkender (P), M Simm (M), N Appleby (P) | N Appleby (P) | J Jobson |
| 1883 | 2-0 St P | R Marr (P), J Davison (P) | J Davison (P) | J Lundy/S Brotherton |
| 1884 | 1-0 St M | J Davison (M) | J Davison (M) | J Lundy |
| 1885 | 2-1 St M | J Davison (P), – (M), R Jobson (M) | R Jobson (M) | W Wakenshaw |
| 1886 | 2-0 St P | G Balmbra (P), W Hind/G Donoho(P) | W Hind/G Donoho (P) | W Wakenshaw |
| 1887 | 2-1 St M | W Hind (M), – (P), A Brown (M) | A Brown (M) | T Moore |
| 1888 | 2-0 St P | T Hind (P), B Thompson (P) | B Thompson (P) | W Wakenshaw |
| 1889 | 2-0 St M | W Thompson 2 (M) | W Thompson (M) | J Whinham |
| 1890 | 1-0 St M | G Hind/G Donowho (M) | G Hind/G Donowho (M) | W Wakenshaw |
| 1891 | Cancelled | Death of the Duchess of Northumberland | | |
| 1892 | 2-1 St P | J Thompson (M), – (P), J Whinham (P) | J Whinham (P) | L Jobson |
| 1893 | 2-1 St P | W Hind (P), Armstrong (M), J Jobson (P) | J Jobson (P) | |
| 1894 | 2-1 St P | Garvie (P), Duns/TC Thompson (M), J Jobson (P) | J Jobson (P) | |
| 1895 | 2-0 St M | H Heatly (M), H Bishop (M) | H Bishop (M) | |
| 1896 | 2-1 St P | J Thompson (M), W O`Brien (P), G Ducken (P) | G Ducken (P) | |
| 1897 | 2-1 St P | R Appleby (P), G Brewis (M), W O`Brien (P) | W O`Brien (P) | |
| 1898 | 2-1 St P | T Haley (P), W Hamilton (M), J Whinham (P) | J Whinham (P) | |
| 1899 | Cancelled | Death of the 6th Duke of Northumberland | | |
| 1900 | 1-1 draw | W Hamilton (M), T Roper (P) | | |
| 1901 | 1-0 St M | J Quinn (M) | J Quinn (M) | |
| 1902 | 2-0 St P | W O`Brien (P), J Black (P) | J Black (P) | |
| 1903 | 1-1 draw | Elliot (M), W O`Brien (P) | | |
| 1904 | 0-0 draw | | | |
| 1905 | 1-0 St M | A Orange (M) | A Orange (M) | |
| 1906 | 1-0 St M | C Wakenshaw (M) | C Wakenshaw (M) | |
| 1907 | 1-1 draw | P Kelly (P), R Schofield (M) | | |
| 1908 | 1-1 draw | T Moore (P), A Orange (M) | | |
| 1909 | 2-0 St M | A Orange, H Knight (M) | H Knight (M) | |
| 1910 | Cancelled | Death of the 7th Duke of Northumberland | | |
| 1911 | 1-1 draw | A Orange (M), N Housby (P) | | W Scott |
| 1912 | 1-0 St M | N Hind (M) | N Hind (M) | W Scott |
| 1913 | 1-1 draw | W O`Brien (P), T Waters (M) | | F Lundy |
| 1914 | 2-0 St P | J Harrison (P), W Lilburn (P) | W Lilburn (P) | J Knox |
| Cancelled | 1915-1919 WW1 | | |
| 1920 | 2-0 St M | W Lilburn (M), J Smith (M) | J Smith (M) | J Pape |
| 1921 | 2-1 St P | S Rickaby (P), D Shiel (M), S Rennison (P) | S Rennison (P) | P Angus |
| 1922 | 1-1 draw | M Thompson (P), S Kirkup (M) | | J Kelly |
| 1923 | 2-0 St P | A McMullen (P), W Athey (P) | W Athey (P) | J Kelly |
| 1924 | 2-0 St M | B Menzies (M), E Hall (M) | E Hall (M) | D Angus |
| 1925 | 1-0 St P | J Yeamens | J Yeamen (P) | L Proudlock |
| 1926 | 1-0 St M | No record | No record | J Angus |
| 1927 | 1-1 draw | A Drummond (M), L Weathernburn (P) | | |
| 1928 | 1-1 draw | R Turnbull (P), D Parker (M) | | T Murphy |
| 1929 | 2-0 St M | T Murphy (M), J Harper (M) | J Harper (M) | T McGregor |
| 1930 | 1-1 draw | W Cockburn (P), J Harper (M) | | W Balmbra |
| 1931 | 1-0 St M | W Wood (M) | W Wood (M) | TMurphy |
| 1932 | 1-0 St P | J Gair (P) | J Gair (P) | J Carlisle |
| 1933 | 1-0 St M | T Roberts (M) | T Roberts (M) | T Murphy |
| 1934 | 2-1 St M | A Lorimer (P), M Navin (M), M Hind (M) | M Hind (M) | A Middleton |
| 1935 | 1-0 St M | W Casson (M) | W Casson (M) | W Balmbra |
| 1936 | 1-0 St P | A McMullen (P) | A McMullen (P) | D Evans |
| 1937 | 2-1 St M | T Murphy (M), N Thompson (P), T Murphy (M) | JT Murphy (M) | T Murphy |
| 1938 | 0-0 draw | | | T Angus |
| 1939 | 2-0 St M | T Murphy (M), H McFadden (M) | H McFadden (M) | J Dowie |
| Cancelled | 1940-1951 WW2 and aftermath | | |
| 1952 | 1-1 draw | P Egdell (P), J Angus (M) | | T Thompson |
| 1953 | 2-0 St M | R Shell (M), G Little (M) | G Little (M) | J MacKenley |
| 1954 | 2-1 St M | J Gray (P), J Brown (M), D Ogle (M) | D Ogle (M) | J MacKenley |
| 1955 | Cancelled | Adverse weather | | |
| 1956 | 2-1 St P | D Douglas (P), no record(M), J Miller (P) | J Miller (P) | J MacKenley |
| 1957 | 2-0 St M | L Beccarelli (M), D Seaman (M) | D Seaman (M) | J MacKenley |
| 1958 | 2-0 St P | B Hossain (P), S Weadle (P) | S Weadle (P) | W Mallaburn |
| 1959 | 1-1 draw | W Mallaburn (M), G Thompson (P) | | F Hopper |
| 1960 | 1-0 St M | Robinson (M) | Robinson (M) | F Hopper |
| 1961 | 2-1 St P | F Cooper (M), M Hornsby (P), R Stevenson (P) | R Stevenson (P) | |
| 1962 | Cancelled | Adverse weather | | |
| 1963 | Cancelled | Adverse weather | | |
| 1964 | 2-0 St M | B Young (M), G Pink (M) | G Pink (M) | G Collins |
| 1965 | 1-1 draw | G Pink (M), J Athey (P) | | L Jobson |
| 1966 | Cancelled | Adverse weather | | |
| 1967 | 2-0 St P | M Hornsby 2 (P) | M Hornsby (P) | Alison Gray |
| 1968 | 1-1 draw | G Gillie (P), G Clark (M) | | E Carlisle |
| 1969 | Cancelled | Adverse weather | | |
| 1970 | 3-0 St M | K Roper (M), T Wall (M), D Pattinson (M) | D Pattinson (M) | K Temple |
| 1971 | 1-0 St M | N Blackburn (M) | N Blackburn (M) | W Vint |
| 1972 | Cancelled | Adverse weather | | |
| 1973 | 2-1 St M | W Miller (M), R Balmbra (P), G Tate (M) | G Tate (M) | W Mallaburn |
| 1974 | 2-0 St P | R Graham (P), G Anderson (P) | G Anderson (P) | V Mallaburn |
| 1975 | 1-1 draw | G Gillies (P), M Smith (M) | | W Mallaburn |
| 1976 | 2-0 St M | M Rogerson (M), K Smith (M) | K Smith (M) | P Stewart |
| 1977 | 2-0 St M | D Smith (M), S McMullen (M) | S McMullen(M) | S Fannon |
| 1978 | 2-1 St P | D Lillie (P), G Mallaburn (M), D Smith (P) | D Smith (P) | S Fannon |
| 1979 | 2-0 St M | M Rogerson 2 (M) | M Rogerson (M) | R Hopper |
| 1980 | 1-0 St P | C Donaldson (P) | C Donaldson (P) | K Smith |
| 1981 | 2-1 St P | C Donaldson 2 (P), no record (M) | C Donaldson (P) | M Rogerson |
| 1982 | 1-1 draw | G Dodds (M), C Donaldson (P) | | G Dodds |
| 1983 | 2-1 St M | M Cook 2 (M), M Deedigan (P) | M Cook (M) | S Powell (St C) |
| 1984 | 2-1 St M | M Rogerson 2 (M), A Mossman (P) | M Rogerson (M) | M Rogerson/G Baston |
| 1985 | 2-0 St M | P Coxford (M), M Rogerson (M) | M Rogerson (M) | M Rogerson/G Baston |
| 1986 | 2-1 St M | R Smith (P), R Hughes (M), M Rogerson (M) | M Rogerson (M) | M Rogerson/G Baston |
| 1987 | 2-0 St M | M Rogerson (M), W Mallaburn (M) | W Mallaburn (M) | M Rogerson/G Baston |
| 1988 | 2-1 St M | M Rogerson (M), R Smith (P), P Anderson (M) | P Anderson (M) | T Spitall |
| 1989 | 2-0 St M | J English (M), P Seaton (M) | P Seaton (M) | G Hirman |
| 1990 | 1-1 draw | L Temple (P), C Brown (M) | | G Pattinson |
| 1991 | 2-1 St M | P Anderson (P), D Angus (M), J Sumner (M) | J Sumner (M) | S Temple |
| 1992 | 2-1 St P | M Rogerson (P), N Egdell (M), I Cook (P) | I Cook (P) | J Davis |
| 1993 | 1-1 draw | C Balmbra (M), S Temple (P) | | M Rogerson |
| 1994 | 1-0 St M | D Swordy (M) | D Swordy (M) | S Temple |
| 1995 | 2-1 St P | G Bell (M), L Smart (P), S Temple (P) | S Temple (P) | B Wood |
| 1996 | 2-1 St P | R Brown (M), J Grieve (P), S Temple (P) | S Temple (P) | S Temple |
| 1997 | 1-0 St M | L Vint (M) | L Vint (M) | J Vint |
| 1998 | 1-0 St P | S Temple (P) | S Temple (P) | I Elliot |
| 1999 | 2-1 St P | K Aitman (M), J Grieve (P), J Lang (P) | J Lang (P) | A Barron |
| 2000 | 2-1 St M | I Jowsey (P), L Pattinson (M), R O`Brien (M) | R O`Brien (M) | P Schnieder (St C) |
| 2001 | Cancelled | Foot and Mouth disease | | |
| 2002 | 2-0 St M | S Michelson (M), G McMullen (M) | G McMullen (M) | S Temple |
| 2003 | 2-1 St P | M Smith (P), M Logan (M), S Temple (P) | S Temple (P) | L Hopper/S Flynn |
| 2004 | 2-1 St P | C Wells, (M), G Potts (P), D Morris (P) | D Morris (P) | M Logan/D Oliver |
| 2005 | 2-1 St M | D Donohoe (M), M Logan (M) | M Logan (M) | S Hilger (St C) |
| 2006 | 2-1 St P | J McEwan (M), A Levy (P), R Baston (P) | R Baston (P) | M Logan/D Flint |
| 2007 | 1-0 St M | J Richardson (M) | J Richardson (M) | S Temple |
| 2008 | 2-0 St P | S Temple (P), R McKenley (P) | R McKenley (P) | L Pattinson |
| 2009 | 1-0 St M | M Fowler (M) | M Fowler (M) | S Temple |
| 2010 | 1-0 St P | S Temple (P) | S Temple (P) | J Imeson |
| 2011 | 1-0 St P | M Hubbard (P) | M Hubbard (P) | R Flint |
| 2012 | 1-0 St P | S Imeson (P) | S Imeson (P) | S Temple |
| 2013 | 2-0 St M | L Pattinson 2 (M) | L Pattinson (M) | S Temple |
| 2014 | 2-1 St P | S Temple 2 (P), J Hume (M) | S Temple (P) | A Miller |
| 2015 | 2-0 St M | R Coxford (M), L Pattinson (M) | L Pattinson (M) | A Miller |
| 2016 | 2-1 St P | L Pattinson(M), S Elliott (P), S Temple (P) | S Temple (P) | A Miller |
| 2017 | 1-0 St M | L Pattinson (M) | L Pattinson (M) | H Brown |
| 2018 | 2-0 St M | L Pattinson (M), S Alderson (M) | S Alderson (M) | S Temple |
| 2019 | 1-0 St M | L Pattinson (M) | L Pattinson (M) | S Temple |
| 2020 | 2-0 St M | A Flanighan (M), L Pattinson (M) | L Pattinson (M) | W McDougall |
| 2021 | Cancelled | Covid-19 | | |
| 2022 | 2-0 St P | S Temple (P), S Temple (P) | S Temple (P) | J Seymour |
| 2023 | 2-1 St M | R Balmbra (P), T Harker (M), S Angus (M) | S Angus (M) | N Adams |
| 2024 | 2-1 St M | T Harker (M), A Miller (P), T Harker (M) | T Harker (M) | S Temple |
Alnwick Hales 